The European Union (EU) Commission proposed a new policy to condition development aid for African countries on their cooperation with migration enforcement. This includes stricter border controls, returns, and readmissions of migrants. Internal EU documents suggest that countries failing to comply could face significant aid cuts. This policy shift, effective under the Global Europe instrument, has drawn sharp criticism from organizations like Oxfam, who deem it a short-sighted political solution rather than addressing underlying issues. The policy comes amid rising pressure within EU nations like Germany, Italy, and Greece to curb irregular migration.
Experts across Africa strongly condemn the EU's approach, describing it as coercive, neo-colonial, and undermining of sovereignty. Maria Ayuk, a postdoctoral researcher, stated that the policy "reduces African nations to border guards rather than equal partners," while Fidel Amakye Owusu, a geopolitical advisor, highlighted socioeconomic problems, poverty, conflict, and unemployment as key drivers of migration. Paul Ejime, a media and global affairs analyst, agreed, emphasizing that "poverty, hardship, and instability" are pushing Africans to migrate. Experts also pointed to governance failures, Europe's extractive trade practices, and the brain drain of skilled workers as contributing factors.
The EU's linking of aid to migration control is widely criticized as exploitative and damaging to long-term relations. Experts argue the approach undermines trust and mutual respect, urging a shift towards reciprocal relations based on equity and justice. While acknowledging African governments' responsibilities, experts stress the need for African unity, strong leadership, and strategic negotiations with the EU to address the root causes of migration. The EU's approach could also backfire, potentially pushing African nations towards partnerships with alternative global powers.
Impact Statement: The EU's new policy may strain relations with African nations, potentially hindering development efforts and fostering resentment while failing to address the root causes of migration.