England defeated Italy in the Euro 2025 semi-final, winning 2-1. However, the victory came despite a largely underwhelming performance, with criticism aimed at manager Sarina Wiegman's tactical decisions and substitutions. Key players like Chloe Kelly and Michelle Agyemang spent significant time on the bench, while the team displayed a lack of cohesion and clear playing style throughout much of the match. The winning goal resulted from a penalty rebound, highlighting the element of luck in the victory.

The match saw Italy's strong defensive display, and England only managed to win due to a fumble by Italy's goalkeeper and a fortunate penalty. The article questions whether England's win was a result of skill or chance, highlighting concerns about the team's performance and tactical approach under Wiegman's leadership. The author suggests a need for England to develop a clearer playing identity and calls for a shift towards younger players.

Impact Statement: England's unconvincing victory raises concerns about their preparedness for the Euro 2025 final and highlights the need for tactical and personnel changes to secure future success. The team's performance also prompts a broader discussion about England's national identity in women's football.